Gatekeepers of the entrance gate to Judaism exposed1. Menuval Leib Tropper, champion of universal standards for Giur, was caught doing things the description of which does not fit this blog.
2. Menuval Tropper was the one who successfully pushed for the delegitimization of the Rabbinical Council of America (RCA), and achieved that conversions done by RCA rabbis are now no longer automatically recognized in Israel.
3. The delegitimization of the RCA happened right after the RCA took the brave step to oust Menuval Mordecai Tendler, after the RCA had established that Menuval Tendler, a long-time Av Beit Din L'Giur, had been doing things the description of which does not fit this blog. The RCA was brave because Menuval Tendler is a grandson of Reb Moshe Feinstein and the main editor of the Iggros Moshe. May the memory of Reb Moshe yet be blessed.
4. Menuval Tropper has great influence on the great rabbis in Israel. A major channel for that influence is rabbi Nachum Eisenstein, head of "Va'ad HaRabbanim HaOlami L'Inyanei Giur."
5. At the time of the Tendler affair, after the truth had become clear to all, it was rabbi Nachum Eisenstein who defiantly invited Menuval Tendler to give a shiur Torah in his Shul in Maalot Dafna.
6. The Psilah of Rav Druckman by the Beit Din headed by Rav Sherman, and the blatantly immoral consequences thereof, occurred after pressure of Menuval Tropper and Rabbi Eisenstein. The delegitimization of Rav Druckman mirrors the delegitimization of the RCA.
7. The ban of the books of Rav Slifkin occurred after Menuval Tropper exerted pressure on the great rabbis of Israel.
8. Rabbi Nachum Eisenstein maintains that someone who does not reject the scientific consensus about the age of the Universe cannot be a Dayan who oversees conversion.
9. Presumably, therefore, Rabbi Eisenstein maintains that someone who accepts the scientific consensus cannot be a Ger Tzedek. Menuval Tropper teaches that someone who does not believe in "Emunas Chachamim" cannot convert.
10. At this time, the rabbis who appoint Dayanim in Israel did not openly relate to the Tropper scandal. We did not hear from who gave Semicha to the Menuval, and not from who supported his work.
11. A couple of days before the scandal broke, a group of rabbis, including Rav Elyashiv and Rav Shteinman, issued a ban against orthodox internet sites. If this was not an attempt to cover up the scandal, it is a case of Mar'it Ayin.
Whether by their support for the Menuval, or by their attempt to cover up, or by their silence, the rabbis stand exposed. It should have been clear before, from the disastrous consequences of left-wing government policies, such as the Oslo agreements and the "Disengagement," which were carried out only by virtue of the support of leading rabbis, or from the rabbis' legal activism in the realm of science: The Emperor has no clothes. The rabbis who seek to rule lack wisdom, knowledge, and morals.
קה